Why might violence be tempting to activists? Why might it be risky to their movements?

Answer:

We agree with a number of Thaler’s points. First, he is right to question those on the outside who tell activists what to do or offer strategic or tactical advice. Local activists know their context best, and specific instructions from outside actors can place activists at great risk. People struggling under such conditions often say they learn the most from being in touch with other activists. But when activists approach scholars or practitioners for information or resources, it is crucial to make sure that a broad range of experience and evidence are publicly available and accessible. That was the purpose of a recent event hosted by the United States Institute of Peace that featured various scholarly and activist perspectives on how movements respond to repression.

Second, we appreciate how the article highlights the role of human agency in the struggle against authoritarianism and other forms of oppression. Civil resistance offers a way for marginalized and excluded groups to wage struggle using a wide range of direct-action tactics that can be used to disrupt injustices and challenge the status quo. It is more than simply an ideal or a normative preference. We also recognize that when activists seek out support or information, they decide for themselves whether the information is relevant to their context, or whether to discard it.

Third, we share his denunciation of repressive state violence targeting unarmed civilian dissenters. It is a regrettable reality that states often respond to those who challenge state power with violent repression, regardless of which methods of resistance they use. This state violence should never be normalized, nor should false moral equivalences or “both sides”-type narratives be tolerated. Outside actors should stand in solidarity with those fighting oppression and prioritize actions that protect fundamental human rights and mitigate violence targeting unarmed dissidents.

Yet we differ on other important points. First, critics often claim that nonviolence is part of a Western hegemonic discourse that reinforces the legitimacy of state violence while simultaneously encouraging oppressed people to carry the unfair burden of good behavior under crushing conditions. Discourses advocating nonviolent resistance are in no way hegemonic, nor are they Western in origin. Over the millennia, states and nonstate groups have justified violence on the basis of its necessity, used cultural relativism as a way to prevent critiques of violence, and persecuted, imprisoned, and executed those who have advocated nonviolent approaches, which threaten two hegemonic discourses—the state’s monopoly on power, and the normalcy and necessity of violence.

Nonviolent resistance has been a counterhegemonic force that challenges both of these dominant discourses. The technique was developed and embraced by people living under colonial regimes throughout the global south, as well as by marginalized and oppressed communities within the West. Despite their views that violence was preferable to passivity, practitioners such as Mohandas Gandhi and Badshah Khan saw mass civil resistance as the only way for them to challenge the violence of Western imperialism on pragmatic grounds. Over the course of the past century, the technique spread from the global south to the United States and Europe, where people fighting racism, sexism, poverty, war, authoritarianism, and economic inequality have seen the strategic value of fighting structural violence by building and wielding inclusive power from below using nonviolent resistance.

Activists from around the world continue to make arguments about the strategic utility of nonviolent resistance, without any nudging from Westerners or Western researchers. Protesters facing a massive crackdown in Baghdad attempted to maintain nonviolent discipline by shouting “Peaceful! Peaceful!” while under fire from security forces. Women in Lebanon have organized human chains to maintain nonviolent discipline in the ongoing movement there, which is now in a particularly delicate phase. Dissidents associated with the Sudanese Revolution insisted on maintaining a remarkable level of nonviolent discipline, despite bloody crackdowns attempting to throw the transition into disarray. And in Algeria, the ongoing movement there has remained both disruptive and restrained in its use of violence.

Our book, Why Civil Resistance Works, presents evidence that mass, broad-based participation is critical to movement success and that movements that rely primarily on nonviolent tactics tend to enjoy more diverse participation, which in turn yields a number of political advantages for the campaign. Updated analyses reinforce these earlier findings, and other research helps to unpack these dynamics at a more granular level.

Explanation:

Violence might be tempting to activist because it can give desired result in less time and could make life after it easier. It might be riskier because  violence demands bloodshed.

The role of violence in Activist movements historically has given mixed results, while some movement became successful like Bolshevik Revolution or English Revolution, the other like Indian National Movement were not so much successful because of the role of violence.

For Activist violence is tempting because it is the easier way to attract the interest of the masses, and it could help in making revolution.

But the role of violence in activist movements are always riskier as it can lead to death, bloodshed, and civil unrest.

Learn more about Role of Activists here:

https://brainly.com/question/1565393

Which slave group was already in the new world when colonist arrived

who would like to discuss the george flody matter

In the 1880s, Congress proposed the Chinese Exclusion Act, which

The House and Senate can only pass amendments to the Constitution if
the amendment receives a majority vote.
the president supports them.
the amendment receives a two-thirds vote.
the judiciary branch supports them.

The system of numerals developed during the Gupta Empire

A. was too difficult for other cultures to understand.

B. spread at the time of the empire, but it didn't last.

C. became the numerals we use today.

D. is only used by Arab countries now.

What was true about the Gulf of Tonkin incident?
A. It showed the military superiority of the South Vietnamese.
B. Congress concluded that it had been caused by China.
C. It showed the willingness of North Vietnam to make peace.
D. President Johnson acted before all the facts became known.

In the house the blank assigns a bill to a committee

HELP ME :( Which of the following is not a requirement for substantial performance? Select one: a. Performance must be 99.9% of what was promised and no less. b. The party must have performed in good faith. c. Performance must not vary greatly from what was promised. d. Performance must create substantially the same benefit as was promised.

During World War I, why was propaganda important for the war efforts?
O Propaganda provided guidance on how civilians could protect themselves.
O Propaganda helped rally support for government war efforts.
O Propaganda encouraged enemy soldiers to surrender.
O Propaganda brought neutral nations into the war.
Save and Exit
Net
S
Mark this and retum

How did the Mukden Incident advance Japanese imperialism?
O A. It gave Japan an excuse to retaliate against the Chinese and gain
control of Manchuria.
OB. It proved Japan's military strength and convinced the Soviet Union
to become Japan's ally.
O C. It allowed the Japanese navy to gain confidence and take over the
major Chinese port of Shanghai.
D. It preoccupied the French military and let Japan more easily
conquer French Indochina.

The United States seeks no territory, no military bases, no favored position. But we have learned the meaning of aggression elsewhere in the post-war world, and we have met it. What was the author’s purpose for including this statement? to explain that the United States hopes to take over North Vietnam to explain that the United States only wants to stop the spread of communism to explain that the threat against South Vietnam should be easy to stop to explain that this will be the first time US troops have faced a communist country


IT IS B

6. How did the construction and completion of the Transcontinental Railroad help the U.S.
achieve its goal of Manifest Destiny?

After his resignation, Nixon said to a TV audience during a speech, "I am not a crook." What is the artist trying to say about Nixon and the missing portions of the recordings?
AM
MC
T
NARORLOCK
Tape gap cartoon by Herblock
Public Domain
The artist is saying that Nixon held on to the recordings long after they were requested because he knew they were his only hope to be found innocent
The artist is saying that because the recordings did match up if they were listened to carefully, the public should not be so negative toward the president.
The artist is saying that because portions of the recordings were missing, the president clearly knew about the burglary and tried to cover up the evidence.
The artist is saying that Nixon was trying to find the missing parts of the recordings and it was only by accident that any recordings were erased.
I

Which sentences make factual statements about Egyptian civilization? Egyptian civilization developed along the banks of the Nile River. Some historians believe that it is one of the oldest human civilizations. The fertile plains near the Nile helped the civilization grow. The bravest of all soldiers were from the Egyptian civilization.

Can anyone help !!!??

What could Buchanan have done to keep the Union (the United States) together?

What was the trip from Africa to the New World called?

Compare Prime Ministers David Lloyd George and Georges Clemenceau's views on how Germany should be treated.

A) George wanted Germany to lose territory while Clemenceau desired large-scale reparations from Germany.

B) Both men wanted Germany to pay reparations but Clemenceau desired large-scale reparations from Germany.

C) George desired large-scale reparations from Germany while Clemenceau wanted to avoid harsh treatment of Germany.

D) Both George and Clemenceau wanted to avoid harsh treatment to Germany.

2. How did growth in Florida impact Native Americans

HOW MANY BRANCHES MAKE UP THE GOVERNMENT AND WHAT ARE THEY CALLED?

What is the name for the use of violence to strike fear into people and achieve political goals?


pacifism


counter-terrorism


terrorism


politicism

Which statements about concentration camps are true?

Choose ALL answers that are correct.

A. Men, women, and even small children were sent to concentration camps.

B. Only Jews were sent to concentration camps.

C. Nazis used concentration camps to murder millions of people.

D. Inmates in concentration camps were starved and brutally treated.

Which of these happened AFTER the Aztecs gained control of the Valley of Mexico?
A)
Shakespeare was born
B)
the Renaissance began
C)
Tenochtitlan was founded
D)
the Mongol Empire was founded​

Which area of the country was NOT ultimately affected by the invention of the cotton gin?
Midwest
South
Far West
North​

HELP ME PLZ!!! What did Classical Greece inherit from Mycenaean civilization? hieroglyphic language city-state structure democratic elections Sophist philosophy

The plan which settled the
representation issue in the new
Constitution was the
A. Virginia Plan
B. New Jersey Plan
C. Great Compromise​

Which first major West Coast city did the transcontinental railroad connect with in 1870?
A. Seattle
B. Chicago
C. Los Angeles
D. San Francisco

Why did sun yat sen begin receiving help from the communists

What were problems faced by the Allied powers after World War II?

A.Rebuilding the economies of Europe

B.Creating new governments in Europe

C.Getting agreement between the powers on European policies

D.All of the above

Which questions should Robert ask himself before investing the $10,000 he inherited? Check all that apply.
How am I protected as an investor?
Are my friends investing in a similar way?
What guarantees are in place so I make money?
D What taxes will I have to pay on this investment?
How do the risks compare to the potential gains?
What are the chances that the investment will fail?